Choosing The Perfect Payment Processor For Your Shopify Store

Payment processors act as a crucial middle-men between your online store and your customers’ financial institutions, ensuring smooth and secure transactions. In order to start a successful eCommerce store on Shopify, it is crucial that you choose a quick and dependable payment facilitator that effortlessly manages financial transactions. When looking at the payment processors available...

Last updated: 31 May 2023 - 9 mins read

Robin Creative Director

Money in a shopping cart in front of the Shopify logo. Illustrating the importance of choosing the right payment processor for your online store.


Payment processors act as a crucial middle-men between your online store and your customers' financial institutions, ensuring smooth and secure transactions.

In order to start a successful eCommerce store on Shopify, it is crucial that you choose a quick and dependable payment facilitator that effortlessly manages financial transactions. When looking at the payment processors available for Shopify, your aim should always be guaranteeing your customers a convenient and user-friendly checkout. In this article, we summarised what to look for when choosing a payment processor and 5 of the biggest payment processors for Shopify out there.

Key Factors to Consider When Selecting a Payment Processor

Prioritising Security and Fraud Prevention

Keep an eye out for payment processors that follow set industry standards such as the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS), as keeping your customer's sensitive data safe is crucial for the success of your business. It's also essential to opt for processors with robust fraud prevention measures in place. This way, you don’t only protect your business, but also safeguard yourself from potential scams and cashback fraud.

Ensuring Compatibility with Shopify

Before finalising a payment processor, verify its seamless integration with Shopify. This compatibility guarantees a smooth checkout experience for your customers and simplifies the setup process for you.

Scalability: Handling Peak Volumes

When delving into the realm of pricing and fees, it's important to examine and compare the diverse pricing structures and transaction fees offered by different payment processors. This careful analysis enables you to gauge how well a chosen payment processor aligns with your budgetary expectations. Ultimately, the goal is to select a payment processor that not only meets your financial requirements, but also provides a seamless and cost-effective solution for your business needs. So take the time to explore the pricing models and associated fees to ensure a harmonious fit with your objectives.

Enhancing User Experience and Customer Support

A user-friendly interface and responsive customer support contribute significantly to your day-to-day operations. Choose a payment processor that offers intuitive dashboards, comprehensive documentation, and reliable support channels to ensure a seamless experience for both you and your customers.

Popular Payment Processors for Shopify

Green globe representing global reach and presence of Shopify, empowering businesses worldwide.


Mollie has managed to first make a name for itself through the extensive variety of payment methods they offer: Whether it's credit cards, digital wallets, or bank transfers, Mollie got it.  What sets Mollie apart is not just their variety of payment methods but also their constant commitment to providing a seamless and hassle-free customer experience, making check-out processes a matter of seconds. 

Their setup process is remarkably user-friendly, allowing businesses to swiftly integrate Mollie's payment solutions into their platforms with minimal effort. Moreover, Mollie takes pride in its transparent pricing structure, ensuring that businesses have a clear understanding of the fees involved. This transparency instils confidence and trust among merchants, empowering them to make informed decisions. 

Furthermore, Mollie's dedication to exceptional customer support further elevates their appeal. Their knowledgeable and responsive support team is readily available to address any queries or concerns, ensuring that businesses receive prompt assistance whenever needed. Mollie is an exceptional choice for businesses seeking a reliable, versatile, and customer-centric payment service provider in the European market.

Payment Depot

A popular payment processing option that stands out within Shopify is Payment Depot. They've got some intriguing features that make them worth considering. One notable aspect is their unique membership-based pricing model. It's like being part of an exclusive club where you gain access to wholesale prices, potentially saving your business a significant amount of money. On top of that, Payment Depot offers a comprehensive suite of tools and features to meet your needs: From secure payment gateways to robust fraud protection and detailed analytics, they've got you covered.


Stripe is a globally recognized payment processor known for its developer-friendly tools and extensive feature set. It supports a vast array of payment methods, making it a popular choice among businesses worldwide.

Say goodbye to the headaches of complicated setup processes; Stripe makes it a breeze to get started. With a user-friendly interface and intuitive tools, you'll be up and running in no time. But it doesn't stop there. Stripe offers a plethora of features that cater to businesses of all sizes. From robust analytics and real-time reporting to customizable payment flows, Stripe puts the power in your hands. And let's not forget about security – Stripe employs state-of-the-art encryption and fraud prevention measures, ensuring the safety of every transaction. Need assistance along the way? Their dedicated support team is just a click away, ready to lend a helping hand. With Stripe, you're not just getting a payment processor; you're gaining a trusted ally in your business journey.


With PayPal, users can create an account and link it to their bank account or credit card. With PayPal, you can send or receive payments online or in physical stores. It offers various solutions for both consumers and merchants, including payment portals, business management services, and credit options.

PayPal prioritises security, providing a protected payment method that doesn't require disclosing sensitive financial information. The platform's popularity and extensive network make transactions faster and more convenient. Whilst PayPal's fees vary depending on the type of transaction, it still manages to offer significantly competitive rates compared to other payment services. With end-to-end encryption and optional two-factor authentication, PayPal ensures the safety of users' transactions.

With its widespread recognition and user-friendly interface, PayPal provides a familiar and trusted payment method for customers worldwide.


Square is a widely recognized payment platform that enables seamless transactions for individuals and businesses alike. With Square, you get out of the box payment processing solutions for both online and in-person transactions. This means that consumers can experience a faster checkout and make fast and convenient payments. 

All your customers need to do is sign up using an email address and link a credit card, debit card, or bank account. Square places a strong emphasis on security, ensuring the protection of users' financial information. In addition to its core payment functionality, Square provides various features such as business management tools and financing options, catering to the diverse needs of business owners and B2B businesses. With its intuitive interface and trusted reputation, Square serves as a reliable payment solution for both merchants and consumers.

Setting Up Your Chosen Payment Processor on Shopify

Step-By-Step Account Creation

To begin the setup process, create an account with your chosen payment processor. Follow their registration process, provide the necessary information, and complete the identity verification procedure.

Configuring Payment Settings with Ease

Access your Shopify admin dashboard, navigate to the "Settings" tab, and select "Payment Providers." From here, simply follow Shopify’s easy on-screen set-up instructions to connect with the payment provider you have previously registered with.

Thorough Testing for Seamless Transactions

Before making your store live, conduct thorough testing to ensure the flawless functioning of your payment processor. Run test transactions using different payment methods to ensure seamless processing and proper order fulfilment.

Boosting Conversion Rate through Optimised Payment Processing

Simplifying the Checkout Experience

Streamline the checkout process by minimising the number of steps required. A simplified and user-friendly checkout experience reduces cart abandonment rates and increases conversion rates.

Embracing Mobile-Friendly Payments

With the surge in mobile shopping, it is essential to offer a mobile-optimised payment experience. Ensure that your chosen payment processor supports mobile payments and provides a seamless checkout process on various devices.

Offering Multiple Payment Methods

Cater to a wide range of customer preferences by accepting multiple payment methods. Allow customers to pay with credit/debit cards, digital wallets, and alternative payment options, providing flexibility and convenience.

Establishing Trust with Visible Signals

Build customer confidence by prominently displaying trust signals such as secure payment badges, SSL certificates, and customer reviews. These signals create a sense of trust and security, encouraging customers to complete their transactions.

Ensuring Robust Security and Compliance

PCI DSS Compliance

In the vast realm of digital transactions, PCI DSS (Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard) emerges as a complex and multifaceted framework designed to fortify the security and confidentiality of cardholder data. PCI DSS lays out an assortment of security requirements and practices that businesses handling payment card information must follow, in order to ensure their customers the highest levels of security. 

From encrypting sensitive data in transit and at rest, bolstering network defences with robust firewalls, and implementing stringent access controls, to conducting regular vulnerability scans and engaging in relentless compliance assessments, PCI DSS leaves no stone unturned ,when it comes to safeguarding the integrity of financial transactions and protecting both businesses and consumers from potential data breaches.

Safeguarding Transactions with SSL Certificates

Secure your website with an SSL certificate to encrypt data transmitted between your customers' browsers and your server. SSL certificates provide an additional layer of security and instil confidence in your customers.

Employing Effective Fraud Prevention Measures

Implement fraud prevention measures provided by your payment processor, such as address verification, CVV checks, and 3D Secure authentication. These measures help protect your business from fraudulent transactions and mitigate potential losses.

Efficiently Managing Payments and Analysing Performance

Woman immersed in 0s and 1s, symbolizing efficient payment processing and performance analysis with the right payment processor for optimal results.

Leveraging Transaction Tracking and Reporting

Utilise the reporting capabilities of your payment processor and Shopify to track transaction details and gain valuable insights into your sales performance. Analyse sales patterns, identify opportunities for improvement, and make data-driven decisions to optimise your business strategies.

Handling Chargebacks and Disputes

Familiarise yourself with the chargeback process and establish protocols to effectively manage and respond to chargebacks or disputes. Promptly address customer concerns, provide necessary documentation, and work towards amicable resolutions to maintain customer satisfaction.

Streamlining Refunds and Returns

Ensure a smooth refund and return process by integrating your payment processor with your Shopify store. Simplify the process for customers and efficiently manage refunds to maintain positive customer experiences.

In Conclusion

Selecting the right payment processor for your Shopify store is crucial for smooth transaction processing, enhanced security, and improved customer experience. Consider factors such as security, compatibility, pricing, and user support when making your decision. With reputable payment processors like Mollie, Stripe, PayPal, and Square available, you can find the perfect fit for your business needs. Streamline your setup process, optimise the checkout experience, and prioritise security to boost conversion rates and drive business growth.

We at Flatline Agency, official Shopify Plus Partners, are here to help you take your business to the next step, including custom development, design, and marketing. If you are interested, please feel free to contact us.


    By signing up you agree with our privacy policy


    To speak with us, call (+31) 613 326 179, send us an email, or reach out to us by chat or What’s App.


    Shopify Summer Editions ’23 – our favourites

    Imagine my Business – Imagine my Store – Imagine my Future This is the hook, Shopify introduces us to the Summer Editions ’23. One of the most powerful updates until now. There have been some changes in the digital world, which automatically affect the eCommerce industry – bringing a lot new opportunities to the field. Personalisation...

    Shopify’s one-page checkout

    By now, we’ve all heard of the Shopify Editions | Winter ’23 and the amazing upgrades that the eCommerce platform will be offering soon.  Shopify is one of the biggest players in the industry, holding a substantial market share in the United States and accounting for over $444 billion in global economic activity. The new...

    B2B with Shopify: Unlocking the Power of Business-to-Business Commerce

    In today’s digital age, eCommerce has revolutionised the way businesses operate and connect with their customers. Shopify, one of the leading eCommerce platforms, not only caters to direct-to-consumer (DTC) businesses but also provides robust features, which Shopify Plus merchants can utilise for business-to-business (B2B) transactions. This article explores the world of B2B on Shopify, its...

    Shopify Markets Pro: The Ultimate Solution for International eCommerce Businesses

    Are you looking to expand your eCommerce business and take over the international market? Yet the complexities of international transactions made you reconsider your decision? Shopify Markets Pro delivers an all-in-one solution that simplifies the process of selling globally. We’ll be showing you all the things you need to know about the new toolkit of...

    The logo of Klaviyo One, a comprehensive customer data platform (CDP) that revolutionises business growth and customer engagement.

    What is Klaviyo One?

    Klaviyo One is the all-in-one platform to grow your business. Klaviyo has always been a powerful email marketing tool, but with the release of Klaviyo One, they are now a complete customer data platform (CDP). This means that you can now manage all of your customer data in one place, and use it to drive...

    Various equipment such as camera are put on the white background

    Omnichannel versus Multichannel

    Omnichannel and multi-channel: what’s the difference? We’re going to be elaborating on the differences between omnichannel and multi-channel. So let’s jump straight into it! So let’s start off with a few definitions. The defintions First of all, when we speak about channels what we mean is a medium through which a brand is able to...

    Title of the blog: WooCommerce migration: A step-by-step guide

    WooCommerce migration: A step-by-step guide on how to navigate your migration

    In the dynamic world of eCommerce, staying ahead means not just keeping pace with technology but leveraging it to your advantage. At Flatline Agency, we’ve observed a significant trend where businesses are transitioning their digital storefronts to platforms that offer more agility, scalability, and user engagement.  Introduction WooCommerce is favoured by many for its seamless...

    Season 2/2: Mastering Framer’s most useful features in 5 minutes

    Learn how to create your new intuitive, and beautiful experiences with Framer Welcome back to our Framer blog series. In our previous blog post, we started discovering how Framer can transform the process of designing, sharing, and publishing websites and prototypes without the need for coding knowledge. Framer is a comprehensive design tool tailor-made for...

    Shopware to Shopify: The best eCommerce tool in 2024

    Switching from Shopware to Shopify should be your next step, but why? Furthermore, how? We’re here to answer all these questions, so don’t worry. Introduction At Flatline, we have noticed a shift in businesses in the digital marketplace. More companies are transitioning from Shopware to Shopify to unlock new growth opportunities and enhance their digital...

    Season 2/1: Framer’s what, how, and why

    Let’s learn how to design, share, and publish your new website faster than ever with no code. At Flatline, we’re excited to announce that we will release a new blog series. This, as the title suggests, will cover how to use Framer to the best of its ability. Our first release will explain “what” Framer...

    From Lightspeed to Shopify: Optimising your migration in 2024

    Migrating from Lightspeed to Shopify is absolutely worth it, but why? And how? Don’t worry, all of these questions will be answered here. Lightspeed and Shopify Identification Lightspeed is a cloud-based commerce platform tailored for retail, hospitality, and golf businesses. It provides a comprehensive set of tools, including point-of-sale (POS) systems, inventory management, and customer...

    ChatGPT 3.5 vs ChatGPT 4: A direct comparison

    The staggering differences between ChatGPT 3.5 and ChatGPT 4, side-by-side. Welcome to our newest blog. Today we’ll be delving into the details of 2 of the most popular AI tools in the world. ChatGPT 3.5 and ChatGPT 4. As some of you may already know, Chat ChatGPT is the paid subscription provided by OpenAI, we’re...


    HubSpot settings: Your clear guide for 2024

    A complete guide to answer all of your questions on how to set up your HubSpot Settings. Welcome to our guide on your HubSpot settings navigation. If you’re new to HubSpot and not sure how or where to start, don’t worry. This guide, along with our complementary videos, will help you through each step to...

    Season 1/4 – Shopify B2B apps

    Shopify B2B apps – the Flatline go-to’s Shopify has brought its B2B game to the next level. There are a lot of opportunities to take from the eCommerce platform and also a lot of apps to be used. We’ll introduce you to the B2B basics of Shopify and our Go to apps, for Shopify Plus...

    Season 1/3 – Shopify multistores

    Shopify multistores – the innovation of merging your online business Shopify has emerged as a beacon for retailers looking to expand their digital footprint. With the introduction of Shopify multistores, businesses now have the capability to manage multiple storefronts under a single umbrella, a feature that has revolutionised the way brands approach online selling. This...

    Season 1/2 – Shopify email setup

    Let us show you how to set up your Shopify email – store owner email and sender email! Email is more than a communication tool for your customers, it’s a real marketing tool that can be used in so many ways. 2024 is definitely an opportunity for you to step up your mail game with...

    This site is registered on wpml.org as a development site. Switch to a production site key to remove this banner.